When It's Not Working: Counsel, Parting, and Protecting the House
How to fire a household employee — and the severance etiquette, honest counsel and quiet paperwork that come before it — in a home that is also a workplace.
Every other piece in this series is about bringing the right people into your house and keeping them. This one is about the harder discipline: what to do when it is not working.
A household is the most personal workplace in the world — the employee who is failing may be failing within sight of your children, your marriage and your morning coffee — and that intimacy tempts families toward the two exits that always go wrong: the slow freeze of unspoken disappointment, and the sudden explosion that ends a livelihood at the kitchen door.
There is a better road, and it is not complicated. Counsel first, honestly and in time to matter. Document what you said.
Part, if parting is the answer, with the money correct, the words few and kind, and the house's doors — literal and otherwise — properly secured. Knowing how to fire a household employee, and the severance etiquette around it, is part of running a great house. Here is the whole of it, done with class.
First, Counsel: Most Failures Are Conversations That Never Happened
Before anything in this article applies, satisfy yourself of one thing: that the person knows, specifically and in words, what is wrong. The household-management counsel is unanimous on the sequence.
Cora Partners' guide to managing staff performance in a private household starts where every fair process starts — clear expectations and written job descriptions from the beginning — and for problems, prescribes constructive, specific feedback focused on behaviours and outcomes rather than criticism of the person, with periodic reviews to discuss improvement and set goals.
That word, specific, does the heavy lifting. "The standard has slipped" is a mood. "The children's breakfast has been late four mornings this month, and on Thursday their school things were not ready" is a conversation somebody can act on.
Hold that conversation privately, promptly and in the right spirit — which is rescue, not prosecution.
Name the behaviour, name its effect on the house, ask what is happening on her side of it, and listen all the way to the end: a surprising share of household underperformance is a training gap, a schedule that quietly became impossible, an instruction two principals gave differently, or a life event she was too proud to raise.
Agree what good looks like, agree a period in which to show it, and put genuine help behind the agreement — training, a corrected rota, a house manager's coaching.
Household Staffing's guidance on staff performance reviews gives the manner of it exactly: keep respect first and foremost, focus on behaviours and outcomes, never personal attacks, and offer solutions — the goal being to build the employee up rather than corner her into defensiveness. Then write it down: date, points, agreement.
A brief note in the personnel file — the file your house built at hiring, as the vetting file describes — protects everyone, including her, because a record of fair warning and real support is the difference between a managed correction and a dismissal nobody can explain.
Distinguish, as you go, between the three different problems that hide under "not working." Cannot is a skills or training gap, and it is the house's to fix or to hire around honestly. Will not is an attitude or conduct question, and it answers to a firmer, shorter conversation.
And wrong fit — the capable, willing professional whose way of working simply does not suit this family's way of living — is nobody's failure at all. Wrong fit counselled early becomes a planned, amicable parting with a strong reference. Wrong fit left to fester becomes the fiction that she was incompetent, which helps no one's next chapter.
The Exceptions: Safety, Honesty and the Immediate Exit
The counsel-first road has one clear exception, and every house should name it in advance. Where the issue is safety — a child endangered, driving that frightens you — dishonesty, theft, a serious breach of confidentiality, or misconduct of that order, the employment ends now, not after a programme of improvement.
The payroll specialists' guidance is blunt on the point: severance is not recommended, and notice is not recommended, where an employee is dismissed for cause of that gravity — you arrange temporary cover rather than keep a person you no longer trust in the role for a notice period.
Even here, class and law both apply: the final pay for all work performed is owed in full and on time, whatever was done, and the conversation itself stays short, factual and unheated. Protecting the house and behaving decently in the same hour is not a contradiction. It is the standard.
When Parting Is the Answer: Prepare Before You Speak
If counsel has run its honest course — or the fit was simply wrong — prepare the parting the way GTM Payroll's household termination guidelines prescribe, because this choreography exists to keep a painful hour from becoming a damaging one.
Gather the file before the meeting: the signed work agreement, performance reviews, the record of absences and conversations — the evidence that the decision is legitimate and documented. Prepare a concise termination letter in advance, with the final payment details inside it. Rehearse what you will say until it is prepared, consistent and concise.
And check the agreement you signed at hiring: many houses promise notice or severance terms in the work agreement itself, and whatever the house promised, the house does — that, too, is protecting the house, because a family's word inside its own staff is its reputation outside it.
The meeting itself follows rules earned by other people's mistakes. Hold it in person — never by phone, text or note — in private, without children or dependents present, and at the end of the workday so there is no long public afternoon after it.
GTM's best-practice guidance adds two refinements worth adopting: state the decision clearly, twice, so there is no merciful ambiguity to unravel later; and have another adult present — your spouse, or the house manager — as witness and as steadiness for everyone in the room. Then allow her response.
A one-way announcement invites grievance; a person who has been heard, even in disagreement, leaves with measurably more of her dignity intact. Keep the explanation short and anchored in the documented record.
The meeting is not the trial of her character, and the kindest thing in the room is brevity: the decision, the arrangements, the thanks for what was genuinely good, and the door held open to the practical questions — final pay, references, belongings, goodbye to the children if that is wise — that she actually needs answered.
The Money: Severance, Notice and the Final Paycheck
A common guideline is one week's pay for every year the employee worked for you.— GTM Payroll Services, on severance for household employees let go through no fault of their own
Severance is, in most places, a matter of agreement and custom rather than legal compulsion — GTM's guidance on severance and notice states it directly: severance is not legally required unless your work agreement promised it, in which case the agreement governs.
Where the parting is no fault of hers — children grown into school, a family relocating, a role that has genuinely disappeared — generosity is the custom of good houses: the guideline quoted above, with notice given as generously as circumstances allow, at least two weeks and often up to four or more.
Where a long-serving employee stays to a date the family needs — the move completed, the replacement trained — a retention arrangement on top is money elegantly spent: she leaves with security, and the house never faces a gap at its most vulnerable moment.
Have the full discipline of payroll behind you here; this is exactly the ground our piece on household employment done legally covers.
The final paycheck is not a courtesy, it is a deadline, and the deadline is your state's, not your payroll cycle's.
Paylocity's state-by-state final paycheck brief shows how widely the rules range: some states require payment immediately at termination, others by the next business day or within a few working days, others by the next regular payday — with states lacking their own law defaulting to federal timelines.
LegalClarity's walk-through of the termination process adds the meeting-room contents: present the final paycheck or its confirmed timing, any accrued paid-time-off payout, and severance details at the meeting itself, with the written notice stating the effective date.
Have the figures calculated and checked before you sit down — by your payroll service, not on a napkin — and include everything earned to the last hour. Nothing sours a decent parting, or invites a wage claim, like money that arrives late, light or argued over.
References, Goodbyes and the Story the House Tells
Decide the reference before the meeting, and match it to the truth. For the wrong-fit and no-fault partings, offer a genuinely good reference and mean it — specific, warm, and given promptly when the next family calls, because in the small world of household service your reference is a currency other principals read carefully.
For a counselled performance exit, an honest, factual reference — dates, role, the strengths that were real — is both fair to her and fair to the family who will rely on it; agree with her what it will say, so nothing ambushes either side later. What a good house never does is retail the parting.
The remaining staff are told simply that she has left and the arrangements for cover, in the same tone you would want used about you.
The children get the simple, kind version appropriate to their age — she is not coming back, it is not their fault, she cared for them — and, where the relationship warrants it and the farewell is safe, a proper goodbye rather than a disappearance. Children remember how the house treated someone on the way out.
So does everyone still working in it.
Protecting the House: Keys, Codes and Confidentiality
The practical close is a checklist, executed the same day without drama: house keys, fobs, remotes and any staff phone or cards returned; alarm and gate codes changed; accounts, apps and access lists updated; the children's school and club lists amended so collection permissions match reality.
GTM's guidelines make one further point that belongs in every termination meeting: reiterate the confidentiality agreement she signed at hiring — what she learned about the family in service is private, and the obligation continues after the employment ends. Say it once, plainly, as a reminder between professionals rather than a threat, and note that it was said.
Then change what needs changing with the unembarrassed thoroughness of a house that would do the same after any departure, amicable or not — good security is a routine, not an accusation, and treating it as routine is itself a kind of grace.
Handled this way, an ending does something quietly valuable for the house that remains. The staff who stay watch a parting conducted with warning given in time, money paid in full, words kept kind and doors secured without theatre — and they draw the correct conclusion about their own security in your service.
The world of household professionals talks, as every small profession talks, and the houses spoken of as fair in an exit are the houses the finest candidates accept first. Counsel early, document honestly, pay exactly, and part like people who may meet again — because in this world, you very often do.
Household Employment, Done Legally: Payroll, Taxes, Contracts, and NDAs
The Vetting File: Background Checks, References, and the Questions That Matter
Black Excellence Profiles — The Women
Cora Partners — "Effectively Managing Staff Performance in a Private Household"
Household Staffing — "Mid-Year Performance Reviews for Household Staff"
GTM Payroll Services — "What to Consider if You Intend on Firing Your Nanny"
GTM Payroll Services — "How to Terminate a Household Employee"
LegalClarity — "The Legal Process for Firing a Nanny"
Paylocity — "Final Paycheck Laws Compliance Brief"
Questions & Answers
Who will you meet on this page?
How to fire a household employee — and the severance etiquette, honest counsel and quiet paperwork that come before it — in a home that is also a workplace. It links to 3 stories and articles — open any card to read the full piece.
What makes these stories worth reading?
How to fire a household employee — and the severance etiquette, honest counsel and quiet paperwork that come before it — in a home that is also a workplace.
How do I read the full stories on When It's Not Working: Counsel, Parting, and Protecting the House?
Choose any card on this page. Each one opens a full page of its own — the complete story or article, with its sources linked.