The Summer Circuit: Oak Bluffs, Sag Harbor and the Houses That Hold Us
Two storied shores, one season: the Black summer vacation homes of Oak Bluffs and Sag Harbor — how the circuit works, and what the old families know about both towns.
Ask where Black America summers and the answer comes back in two place names, spoken the way other families speak of a grandmother's house: Oak Bluffs and Sag Harbor. The Black summer vacation homes of these two towns are not really real estate.
They are membership rendered in shingle and porch rail — addresses that say your people have been arriving here, on purpose, for generations, and intend to keep arriving. The summer circuit runs on that continuity: the same ferry, the same beach at the same hour, the same porch at dusk, the grandchildren taller every year against the same doorframe.
This is the circuit explained from the porch side: how the two towns earned their place, how to rent on them well, what buying actually involves, and the courtesies that keep a house — and a summer — in the family.
Oak Bluffs: The Town That Let Us Buy
Oak Bluffs began as a Methodist camp meeting ground, all gingerbread cottages and revival tents, and became something the rest of the resort coast would not allow: a place where Black families could purchase homes.
As one recent tribute tells it, in an era when the resort coast largely closed its doors — and its deeds — to Black travellers, Oak Bluffs stood apart as a place where Black families could actually purchase houses, welcome friends and relatives into them, and return summer after summer until a holiday became a heritage.
The emblematic address is Shearer Cottage: Charles Shearer, born enslaved, and his wife Henrietta ran a laundry there from 1903, and in 1912 the family converted it into an inn for Black vacationers — guests over the years included Paul Robeson and Madam C.J. Walker, and descendants of the Shearers operate it still.
Walk the African American Heritage Trail, take in the three hundred and more painted gingerbread cottages around the Tabernacle, and you are reading the town correctly: faith, enterprise and leisure, braided together for over a century.
A safe place where we can go as we are and not be questioned.— Maya Angelou on Martha's Vineyard, as recalled by WDC TV
The town's daily sacrament happens early, at Inkwell Beach. The Polar Bears — a swimming circle founded in 1946 — meet on the sand at 7:30 each morning through the season for water aerobics, laps and a closing meditation in the water, a Monday potluck breakfast on the beach drawing in the admirers who never get wet.
The circle, as the island guides describe it, welcomes whoever shows up in a swimsuit, at whatever age: be on the sand before half past seven, wade in with the group, and ask before you film.
Guests of the house who join once tend to set their alarms for it all week; there is no better introduction to what the circuit actually is — not display, but fellowship with a long memory.
Sag Harbor: SANS and the Self-Financed Shore
Across the water in Sag Harbor, the twin story wears a different accent: not an inn but a subdivision, built by its own residents.
The communities called SANS — Sag Harbor Hills, Azurest and Ninevah Beach — were founded between 1947 and 1952 by Black families creating a summer place of their own; Brooklyn schoolteacher Maude Terry found the buyers and helped them arrange mortgages, and her sister Amaza Lee Meredith, the pioneering architect, designed houses there.
The Preservation League's reading of the record is blunt about the economics: these were families who raised their own financing in an era when the mortgage door was routinely shut to Black buyers, and built anyway — modest mid-century houses on roughly 154 acres along Sag Harbor Bay that remain remarkably intact.
The district's significance is now official: added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2019 and honoured, as the local coverage summarises it, for what it means to Black history and to a community planned by its own residents.
In its heyday the little shore drew Lena Horne, Paul Robeson and Langston Hughes to its cookouts and soirées; today it draws their grandchildren's grandchildren, which is precisely the point.
Hold the two towns side by side and the pattern clarifies. Oak Bluffs is the social shore — the harbor, the carousel, the cottages, the beach at dawn — where the season is a reunion conducted in public, beautifully. SANS is the quiet shore: wooded lanes, modest houses, a bay beach, and privacy as the luxury.
Established families often keep a foot in both traditions across a lifetime — rent the lively town in the children's small years, buy the quiet one when the grandchildren arrive and the porch matters more than the promenade.
Renting on the Circuit, Done Properly
The first law of the circuit is the calendar. Desirable summer houses are reserved well before the season, and for peak weeks — high summer, holiday stretches, the island's big event weekends — the experienced guidance is to begin the search several months in advance, with three- and four-bedroom homes near town, beach and ferry especially competitive.
Work with the island's local agencies as well as the platforms; the house that suits a three-generation party — ground-floor bedroom, outdoor shower, a porch that seats twelve — is often described in a broker's notebook better than in a listing's adjectives.
Before you sign, confirm the unglamorous list: exact bedroom and bathroom count, the linen policy, every fee, payment deadlines and cancellation terms.
Then the ferry, which is the circuit's true front door.
The Steamship Authority carries cars from Woods Hole and requires advance vehicle reservations, and summer vehicle space is limited — one widely used island guide puts passenger fares in the $17–$40 round-trip range and bringing a car at roughly $200–$300, and its advice is the old families' advice: book the boat when you book the house, months ahead, not after.
Foot passengers travel lighter and freer — the down-island towns are walkable and the island bus connects them — but a party arriving with elders, small children and a week's provisions should treat the car reservation as the first booking of the season, not the last.
Sag Harbor asks less choreography: you simply drive onto the lane, which is its own quiet luxury, and wave at three porches before you reach yours.
Provision the house like a small hotel and the season runs itself.
The circuit's veterans rent houses with proper kitchens and cook most breakfasts and half the dinners at home — the island guides make the same point in plainer language, noting that a house with a kitchen is where the money is saved and, not coincidentally, where the family actually gathers.
Bicycles do the short work of both towns: the same guide puts bike hire around $30–$50 a day against $80–$150 for a rental car, and a bicycle never once needs a ferry reservation.
Stock the porch before the first guests land — coffee, something cold, something sweet, towels that are not precious — and keep a house notebook by the door: the plumber who answers, the fish market that delivers, the neighbour with the spare key and the long memory.
A rented house provisioned this way stops feeling rented by the second morning, which is exactly how renters become buyers, and how the circuit has always renewed itself.
Buying, and What the Old Families Know
Buying on the circuit is rarely a transaction; it is an adoption — of a house, a lane and a set of obligations. The old families' counsel, gathered across both towns, runs consistent.
Buy the porch, not the square footage: summers are lived outside, and the house with the deep shaded porch and the outdoor shower will be loved harder than the one with the grand interior. Buy within walking distance of the water your family actually uses, not the famous beach across town.
Expect the house to be passed, lent and argued over like any heirloom — which means buying with the second generation in the room, and putting the sharing arrangement in writing while everyone still likes each other: who opens, who closes, whose weeks are whose, and how the roof fund is fed.
In SANS, know that you are also buying into a preservation story: the village has moved to conserve the communities' essential character and scale while protecting long-term homeowners' equity, and alterations there are a conversation with history, not just with a contractor.
And everywhere on the circuit: a modest house held for fifty years beats a grand one flipped in five. The asset is the continuity.
The Season's Calendar, and the Wider Circuit
Every circuit runs on a calendar its regulars know by heart.
In Oak Bluffs, walk the African American Heritage Trail as a house ritual — an hour or two, best done in the cool of a morning, taking in Shearer Cottage, Union Chapel and the Cottagers' stops among its markers — and let the town supply the evenings: band concerts at the Ocean Park gazebo, and a ride on the Flying Horses, the nation's oldest platform carousel, charming children there since the 1880s.
The season's set piece is Grand Illumination Night, when the gingerbread cottages around the Tabernacle glow with lanterns and the whole campground turns out to admire them — the one evening no house party should compete with.
Sag Harbor keeps a lower, longer register: bay swims, lane walks, the village's galleries and bookshops, and dinners that begin as six and end as fourteen because the lane keeps arriving. Neither town asks to be conquered. Both reward the family that settles into the rhythm and lets the season accumulate.
And know that the circuit is wider than two towns, because our summer geography was built wherever a shore would have us.
Down the coast in Maryland, Highland Beach was founded in 1893 by Charles Douglass — youngest son of Frederick Douglass — after he and his wife were turned away from a Chesapeake resort; he bought shoreline from a Black farmer, divided it into lots for friends, and built his father a house there that stands today as a museum.
The pattern repeats along the Atlantic — enclaves founded in the same decades, for the same reason, kept by the same kind of families — and the histories of those resorts read like one long family album: exclusion answered with ownership, ownership ripening into tradition.
Oak Bluffs and SANS sit at the head of that table, but a family that summers on the circuit should know the whole table is theirs — and should teach the children the names of the other houses, the way you teach them the names of cousins.
Hosting on the Circuit
A summer house on these shores carries a social duty, and it is a pleasure: the porch is semi-public infrastructure.
Host the way the towns taught us — a standing invitation for coffee that requires no occasion, one proper dinner a week for the lane, beach chairs lent without ceremony, and houseguests folded in under the old rules of the good guest and the unflappable host.
Program the house gently: heritage-trail mornings in Oak Bluffs, band concerts at Ocean Park, one sail, one clambake, and long unstructured afternoons in which the season does its slow work on everybody. Keep the guest book. Keep the photograph wall current.
The circuit renews itself exactly this way — a rented house becomes a bought house, guests become neighbours, and a child who once slept in the bunk room arrives, decades later, with children of her own, asking whether the porch still gets the evening breeze. It does. It always did.
That is the whole inheritance, and it is why the houses hold us: not because they are grand, though some are lovely, but because they remember us kindly, season after season, and teach each new arrival exactly where the glasses are kept, which step creaks, and what time the light comes through the porch screens in the morning.
The Summer House Season
The Heritage Journey: Ghana, the Lowcountry, and Going Home in Style
Being a Guest: Weekend Rules
First Mansion Mistakes: Buying Big Without Buying Trouble
Profiles: Real Estate & Mortgage Owners
WDC TV — "A Love Letter From Black Women to Martha's Vineyard"
The Clio — "Shearer Cottage, Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard"
Preservation League of New York State — "Further Reading on Sag Harbor's SANS Community"
Spark Hamptons — "Sag Harbor's Historic Black Beachfront Communities Take Center Stage at The Church"
MV Vacation — "Inkwell Beach, Oak Bluffs: History, the Polar Bears and How to Visit"
Life Is a Journey Escapes — "Where to Stay on Martha's Vineyard: Towns & Rentals"
JayLynn Little — "Martha's Vineyard Guide: Oak Bluffs, Black History & August Travel"
Anchor Realty MV — "Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard"
Edwardian Promenade — "These Summer Resorts Once Offered African Americans Sun, Jazz, Food, and Relaxation During the Jim Crow Era"
Questions & Answers
How do seasoned travelers plan a trip that feels effortless?
Two storied shores, one season: the Black summer vacation homes of Oak Bluffs and Sag Harbor — how the circuit works, and what the old families know about both towns. It links to 5 stories and articles — open any card to read the full piece.
What separates a good trip from a great one?
Two storied shores, one season: the Black summer vacation homes of Oak Bluffs and Sag Harbor — how the circuit works, and what the old families know about both towns.
How do I read the full stories on The Summer Circuit: Oak Bluffs, Sag Harbor and the Houses That Hold Us?
Choose any card on this page. Each one opens a full page of its own — the complete story or article, with its sources linked.